Engineering firms of all sizes are winning more business, working more efficiently, and maximizing profits with design and analysis software that offers the true, proven ability to work seamlessly with other tools.
In an industry that increasingly relies on Building Information Modeling (BIM) to conceptualize, plan, detail, create and guide the building of structures, forward-thinking engineers are looking for ways to bring the same efficiency, accuracy, and collaboration benefits of 3D modeling to their analysis and design work.
Collaborate and save time with seamless BIM integration
For most engineers, working with a number of different analysis and design tools for a single project is the standard, but it is proving more and more difficult. An engineer may use as many as five analysis and design tools on a single project. One tool is used to create a model for steel frame design, another for concrete slab design, and the list goes on. After the various models are created, they are usually combined into a new BIM model from scratch – wasting time and increasing the potential for errors.
Adding to the problem has been the lack of interoperability between software programs, many of which claim to integrate easily with others but fall short. This inability to quickly move a model from analysis and design tools to a BIM software program and share it with other stakeholders throughout the design process often diminishes the benefits of using a 3D model in the first place.
Dan Kilbert PE, LEED AP and Director of Health Care Services at structural engineering firm GRAEF, tried several different analysis and design software tools, all of which promised to integrate seamlessly with various brands of BIM software, but none of which delivered.
We were using multiple analysis and design tools but couldn’t successfully pass the model from those tools to BIM software being used by architects.
“We were using multiple analysis and design tools, but couldn’t successfully pass the model from those tools to BIM software being used by architects,” said Kilbert. “On several projects, we tried to pass an analytical model to our BIM software, but it was very fickle and if we were to pass it back to make adjustments, the link between the two programs would always break. It was hard to get that working, so we would end up doing things the old way of hand sketching or handing it to a technician to have them draft or model it.”
John Funk, PE, structural department head at the architectural firm Hollis + Miller experienced the same challenges and turned to Tekla Structural Designer because of its ability to truly integrate with Trimble’s Tekla Structures and other BIM software programs.
“Interoperability is critical and is a big part of the overall time savings in analysis and design,” said Funk. “Tekla Structural Designer delivers on this promise", said Funk.
Tekla Structural Designer was developed specifically to help design engineers maximize collaboration with other project parties, including technicians, fabricators and architects. Its unique functionality allows engineers to integrate the physical design model seamlessly with Tekla Structures and other leading BIM software, and to round-trip without compromising vital design data.
“Other tools have tried to master BIM integration the way that Tekla Structural Designer does, but they’ve failed,” said Kilbert. “The interoperability and collaboration it enables is bulletproof and has been a huge time saver.”
Structural Engineer and Principal, Adam O’Kane of Leigh & O’Kane evaluated every analysis and design software on the market, looking for one that could provide the interoperability his firm needed.
“We went through every player in the software industry in search of the one that would integrate well with our BIM software,” said O’Kane. “Tekla Structural Designer is the best on the market.”
Work in one product, one interface, one model
Unlike traditional analysis software, Tekla Structural Designer can be used to create physical, information-rich models that contain all the intelligence needed to fully automate design and manage project changes for faster, more accurate design.
From scheme to detailed design, one single model can contain all structural analysis and design requirements. Working in Tekla Structural Designer, engineers don’t have to waste time switching between multiple software packages.
“We can design steel and concrete in one software program and don’t have to create multiple models, jump between software programs, or design and analyze by hand. Consolidating all of those things, along with the fact that Tekla Structural Designer truly integrates with our BIM software, has been incredibly valuable and saved us a great deal of time,” said O’Kane.
Working in one program has changed the workflow for Leigh & O’Kane engineers.
“I like that everything is all in one piece and I don’t need to buy a version to design floor framing and another to do lateral analysis. I also don’t have to bounce back and forth between software programs to get a complete building design,” said O’Kane. “Before, we had to mark things, such as beam reactions or beam sizes, up on our plans by hand. Now, those automatically come through on the Tekla Structural Designer model. That automatic transfer of information saves us a tremendous amount of time and reduces errors.”
O’Kane found that in addition to the efficiency gains of working in one model, the features and capabilities of Tekla Structural Designer made model creation much easier.
“The way we are able to create a new model in Tekla Structural Designer is far superior to anything else on the market. I’ve used other software programs where it was so cumbersome that I would BIM software to create the model, send it to the analysis and design software and then send it back to the BIM software,” said O’Kane. “I no longer have to endure that complex process because I actually enjoy building models from scratch in Tekla Structural Designer.”
O’Kane also found it easy to get up and running.
“When I start a project, I want to quickly and intuitively model. Most other analysis and design software programs fall short and are not intuitive in the least. You have to use the software for years before becoming proficient,” said O’Kane. “This is where Tekla Structural Designer shines. There is no learning curve.”
Easily manage design changes
Effective change management is critical for staying on task and within budget, especially on complex construction projects. For Leigh & O’Kane, the ability to quickly make changes to only one model yielded significant time savings.
“Our first project with Tekla Structural Designer was an irregularly shaped building and required highly complex framing. We were able to model around those irregularities and manage changes without error, which in a complex structure like this, could have had a dramatic ripple effect if a mistake was made modeling across different tools or making changes by hand,” said O’Kane.
Changes in Tekla Structural Designer can be easily managed for reduced response time at any stage of a project, and applied across the entire model to instantly assess impact and automatically get a re-design in seconds.
“We like that it gives us the opportunity to make changes very quickly. Having a 3D model really helps improve the speed at which we can react to changes and practice value engineering,” said Funk.
“It was a leap of faith but our pilot was a hospital – a pretty big project for trying a new software program. We had a lot of confidence in Tekla Structural Designer and what it could do, and it didn’t disappoint,” said Kilbert.
“In terms of efficiency alone, we’ve seen about a 5 percent savings in time, which may not sound like a lot, but it is significant considering the margins that engineering offices run at these days.”
Create more accurate bids and win more projects
Tekla Structural Designer includes all the critical information needed to fully automate design to an engineer’s chosen building code, so less time is spent processing analysis data.
Because Tekla Structural Designer is fully automated, engineers can easily create and compare a range of design schemes and determine the most cost-effective material or solution for projects. This allows Leigh & O’Kane to bid on projects more effectively, with minimal effort.
“It’s really easy to do a quick comparison of materials for a structure and present that back to the architect, along with the pros and cons of each,” said O’Kane. “With Tekla Structural Designer, we can create one model in steel and one in concrete to see which is more economical. It’s extremely valuable to do this on the front end of a job, with little effort and without spending a lot of time creating the models. It’s definitely a competitive advantage that the architects and owners appreciate.”
Transform your business
“Tekla Structural Designer delivers on everything it claims and is a high-end design program, with no limitations on size or complexity,” said Funk. “It’s been very powerful and has all the capabilities we need to work faster and smarter.”
From seamless BIM integration to a quick comparison of design schemes and cost-effective change management, Tekla Structural Designer has all the features engineering businesses need to win more work, increase efficiency and maximize profits.
“Tekla Structural Designer has brought significant value to our business,” said Kilbert. “We’ve phased out other programs and intend to use Tekla Structural Designer for analysis and design exclusively.”